Someone asked me this on our community Q&A last week, and I got about half an answer out before we ran out of time.
He’s in the middle of working through his positioning right now, and he wanted to know what comes after. Is there a cadence for reviewing it? Are some parts monthly and some quarterly?
I told him I’d write it up. This is the other half.
Yes, review it, and put it on a schedule. I recommend that to every agency I work with.
The bigger issue I see runs the other way, though. Owners change their positioning about every 90 days, and it never gets the time to stick.
A few minutes later on that same call, a newer member said she’d spent three months getting clear on her positioning and has had it out in the world for about two. She’s already hitting moments where it feels too generic, or like she has too many competitors. Her instinct was to hold tight a while longer.
I think she’s right to hold.
Two months feels like forever when you’re the one staring at it every day. Your buyers aren’t staring at it. Positioning gets tested by people seeing it, and two months on a calendar tells you nothing about how many people did.
So I split this into two jobs. Reviewing is checking what the market is telling you, and it goes on the calendar. Changing is a decision, and it has to earn its way in.
Reviewing first.
Once a month, take 45 minutes and answer four questions:
Did our positioning start a conversation that didn’t come from a referral?
Did a prospect describe their problem in our words before we said them?
What proof did we pick up this month, and where have we used it?
Who did we turn down?
Nothing gets decided in that meeting. You write down what happened, and three months from now you have a record to look at when the doubt shows up.
Once a quarter, score it. Take the handful of things you claim make you different and rate each one from 1 to 10 on how well you could prove it to a stranger today. Put the numbers next to last quarter’s.
If one of them hasn’t moved in two quarters, you’ve either been neglecting it, or it’s as strong as it’s going to get. Write down which one you think it is. That sentence is more useful than the score.
If you’re crushing it and the calendar is full of the right calls, you can stretch the quarterly one. I’d still keep the monthly.
Once a year, ask the question you can’t answer from inside the business. Has your buyer’s world moved enough that the problem you talk about is no longer the one they feel?
That yearly check is the only one I’d let reopen everything.
Now changing.
Before a change, I want a hypothesis written down. With this positioning, we believe we’ll get this outcome, as long as we do these specific things. Keep the moving parts few enough that somebody else could run the same test and get the same read.
Then put it in front of at least 10 people before you decide anything.
If all 10 say no, good. Now you know it’s a no. If the first five are an angry no, you’re far enough off that you can stop early.
What you can’t do is show it to two people, get a shrug, and rewrite the homepage on Sunday night.
A lot of the time the test tells you something smaller anyway. The positioning is fine and the way you’re describing it is what’s off. Then you rewrite the headline and leave the positioning alone.
(I once had a client get 3 no’s in a row on an offer and immediately wanted to scrap it. I asked them to hold fast because they weren’t hard no’s. Sure enough, the next 4 said yes. We wouldn’t have gotten those if we’d changed the offer. The same concept goes for your positioning. Set a hypothesis and stick to it.)
One exception. If you’re still working it out and none of it is public yet, change it as often as you like. The member who asked the question is changing his from one day to the next right now, and that’s what this stage is for. The clock starts when buyers can see it.
This week, put a 45-minute block on the first Monday of every month and paste those four questions into the invite.
If you’ve held your positioning steady for a while and you’re itching to rip it up, count how many buyers have seen it first. I’m guessing it’s fewer than 10.
Get after it.
Want to join the calls where we discuss questions like this?
Check out the Dynamic Agency Community. It’s only $97/year and gets you access to the peers, advisors, and resources that are sure to solve even your greatest agency challenges.

